Y’know,
I don’t like reading instructions. Well, that isn’t true. I do like reading instructions, I just don’t like following them. As my stinker sister implied I had not Read The Fancy Manual (RTFM)…
In fact, I was actively following the instructions. Those wily Swedes make a nice instruction manual. Everything you need to setup a futon on exactly 2 pieces of paper, cunningly folded to make a 3 page book, consisting of about 18 or so pictures.
However, the bolt icon used to indicate “Do you have X?” for each bolt type contained in the package, is different than the generic “Bolt these two things here.” bolt icon used to indicate that two given pieces are to be connected. Hence, the fact that I was reading the instructions actively didn’t help.
Which brings me to the next tale of instructional woe. We have some stupid processes where I work, and some of them I’m not allowed to fix, I just have to play along. So, I was assigned a task, which was fairly complicated and much hated by all, but I accepted since it was my turn. They gave me the instruction manual, and off I went.
At around step 10, nothing was working right, so I asked the resident expert. “Did you do step 0-C?” he asked? Step 0, being the first step before Step 1, the first step in the manual. “No. I only did steps 0-A and 0-B.”
“Start over from the beginning and do all three of those, it should work…” He said.
So, I started over, got to step 10, and the same problem, so I asked him again what was wrong, and then I learned about step 0-D…
“Well, you have to do 0-D too. Start over from the beginning.” He replied.
“What is this, the Spanish Inquisition?” I asked… He just laughed…
So, again, I started over. And then I followed the instructions to a tee, and when I got to the end, it didn’t work. By now, I had reinitiated the process 3 times and had (apparently) avoided a very serious train wreck while performing another set of unlisted instructions.
By the end, a few of us had gathered around to see if it would all work, and there it was, not working. Then our expert says, ‘Oh, you did all the steps. There were two you should have skipped.”
“Of course I did all the steps! Why are there steps that shouldn’t be done in the list of steps that should?”
A short discussion later, we were able to, thankfully, fix the problem without starting over.
And here is my point. I don’t generally follow instructions because instructions are generally not well written. I find I have better luck if I have to figure things out as I go, since I’m forced to actively think about what is going on, rather than just follow the script.
Granted, much of what I was doing at work required consistency, so the instructions were useful. However, some stuff I could have done better if I thought about what I was doing, rather than doing what I was told.
Same thing with the futon. If I was flying solo, I would have considered each bolt for the job I was employing it to do, rather than trusting the instructions to make the distinction. Since I would have been thinking about the task, rather than the action, I might have made a better decision.
By the same token, if I had been working with someone else, I would have probably said something like “These bolts sure seem long…’ and then that might have sparked a discussion about bolt waste, and we’d have noticed some bolts were less wasteful for the task at hand. We’d have been thinking about the task, and not the action.
So, this is why I don’t like following instructions. Sure, many things might go easier, some stuff would also be harder. It boils down to a choice. Would you rather:
Do moderately well, and make a mistake because someone told you to.
Do moderately well, and make a different mistake because you’re a bonehead.
I pick the latter. I don’t mind cleaning up messes that result of my own stupidity nearly as much as i mind cleaning up after other idiots. Furthermore, if I make a mistake as a result of my own boneheadedness, I learn something, generally a unique mistake not to repeat. If I make a mistake because I’m taking instruction from a proxy (manual), I only learn not to trust proxies.
This is particularly unfair as I’m sure that there are many trustworthy proxies out there who are needlessly maligned by the actions of some thoughtless manuals…
And for the record, the same goes for pulling over and asking directions. Most of the time I’m lost I can’t easily describe where I’d like to be, and there is no reason to expect that a random person on the street might be prepared to guide me there.
It isn’t that I don’t want to admit I am lost, I freely admit that. I’m lost often and I love it. What I don’t want to do is compound my error by placing my trust in a proxy of unknown value, and thereby failing to learn enough about my environment to find my way on my own when I’m next in a similar situation.
So there is my “Think for yourself, mess up and be proud.’ Rant